Noah Koff

Essays

About

Diagnostic

Contact

At 54, I did something crazy

At 54, I did something crazy. I went back to school.

I trained as a mediator and committed to a year of volunteering in small claims court. It was the start of a new, higher purpose for me: repairing relationships through communication.

And yes, there was self-doubt. Was it too late to retrain, and to take my work in a whole new direction? I’m not a lawyer. Would I even be good at this? Those were just a few of the questions that kept me up at night.

In this midlife season, I’ve been getting better at slowing down. At trusting my big self, the one who says, “You’ve got this.” And at listening less to my little self, who hangs out in the shallow end, worries about what could go wrong, and holds me back from being brave, getting uncomfortable and stretching in the direction that moves my life forward.

Less midlife crisis. More midlife radical move.

The ground shifted

In less than two years, I went through a divorce and a job that didn’t work out. I moved out of our family home, where my kids grew up, into an apartment with my dog. I spent a summer living in a friend’s guest room.

The grief came in waves. A twenty-plus-year marriage that ended. A home I lost. A job that failed. And underneath it all, the loss of my identity as a successful person. I’d always been able to land on my feet. This felt different.

I call it Stress Mountain. When the divorce was final, I thought I’d reached the top. It was a false summit. A few months later, I lost my job, and there was another climb ahead.

My WTF moment came when the sale of our family house fell through. The bets I’d made to bring in quick cash weren’t paying off. I wrote one question in my journal:

“Can I make a living being who I am?”

The conversations we avoid

The silver lining: I finally had time to slow down and look honestly at the conversations I had been avoiding, including with myself.

One of them was with a client. Last year, I worked as a fractional growth lead for the founder of a membership fitness business. I built a paid media funnel, and by my scoreboard, it was working. The business’s email list grew 4.6x. Free-trial sign-ups were coming in. I could see the pipeline taking shape.

The founder was keeping a different scoreboard. She saw what the ads cost, and that most of her new members were people she already knew. Meanwhile, the scope of my work grew, but I didn’t put that in writing. When I asked to bill for the extra work, she reminded me that she wanted to stay within budget.

A few days later, she ended our engagement by email. Her reason was trust.

My first reply defended my numbers. Days later, I wrote back with what I should have led with: “I hear you. I take responsibility for the breakdown in our process and communication.” I offered one last call to end on a better note, and she said yes. But by the time I sent meeting options, the moment had passed. We never had that conversation.

Here’s what I came to understand. We were both under financial heat. She was watching her ad spend. I was watching my income. That kind of pressure pushes reasonable people into rash decisions. We throw out everything rather than fixing the flaws we’ve found, or turn on the very people who want us to succeed. She cut the engagement. I kept defending my scoreboard instead of hearing hers.

That’s what avoided conversations cost. People get blamed. Work is abandoned. When dreams don’t work out, we retreat. We privately nurse our resentments rather than talking things through and supporting each other.

The realization

After 20+ years coaching leaders, I now see it clearly. Many performance problems are really problems of communication, expectations, and unresolved conflict.

In the interviews I’ve been running with revenue managers on AI adoption, the same pattern of avoidance keeps showing up. When a question can’t be answered, it is often ignored. It doesn’t get escalated because raising it feels too risky. It feels easier to keep moving forward than to pause and have a hard conversation.

The question is, how do you help people through these hard conversations?

Choosing to begin

I enrolled in 32 hours of mediation training at Portland Community College to find out.

The first thing I learned was to sit in the silence, instead of rushing in to save people with solutions. That’s how two people work through pain, fear, guilt, and shame, instead of going around them.

One role-play stuck with me. I played Jim, a homeowner whose garbage bins kept overflowing into the street while I was away at the beach with my family. Laura, my neighbor, came in hot: I hadn’t shown much pride of ownership, and I’d seemed dismissive every time she tried to talk to me.

Then the mediator named what we both wanted: a nice street, and no garbage by the drain. “I want to keep it nice too, Laura,” I said. “I really do.” And then, in character: “I am not the best communicator. My wife tells me that all the time.”

By the end, we had a plan. A second bin. A text when we’re away. An email before any change that touches her side of the fence. Even the nail sticking out of that fence made the list. Apparently I had a nail problem.

Not a winner and a loser. A way forward.

What surprised me most: those skills aren’t just for a courtroom or a conflict at work. They work at home. Understanding what your ex needs for the kids’ Christmas break.

When my ex-wife and I split, it was “You get the dog, I get the juicer.” A year after our divorce, nearly to the day, she asked me, “Do you want the juicer?”

We’d listened our way from a negotiation to a repair.

What evolved was my thinking. I stopped trying to win negotiations and started trying to understand. I showed up for the new dynamic in our family instead of keeping score.

The work is also teaching me about myself. In another role-play, I was the mediator between two people in a heated dispute. Early on, she said he had been “mansplaining.” I repeated the word back to show her I’d heard her. It felt empathetic. To him, it sounded like I’d agreed with the accusation, and he shut down right in front of me. My trainer’s advice: normalize it for both of them. They were both under stress, and saying so out loud lowers the temperature for everyone.

The next time, I tried what William Ury calls “going to the balcony” in his book on negotiation, Getting Past No: pausing to see the conversation from a distance before reacting. I took a breath and looked for what Ury calls a “golden bridge,” a way forward both people can cross without losing face. Then I named what they both wanted, without reaching for the word that would make someone shut down.

I recognized my own pattern in a dispute. I can be too blunt and too direct, and I rush. The finesse is in slowing down. Take a beat. Take a breath. Don’t tiptoe around the awkward conversation, but come at it attuned to the other person’s needs and feelings.

That’s the work I want to do. Instead of blaming, sidelining or pushing people out, help people learn to fight better.

Priya Parker makes the case in her book, The Art of Fighting: “The most meaningful human connection is forged not because you have avoided conflict but because you have confronted it. If you want to be more connected to the people in your life, fight more. And learn the art of doing it well.”

The invitation

So, can I make a living being who I am? I don’t know yet, but I’m finding out.

Here’s what I do know. I’m not just following my passion. I make my living the way I have for years, as a fractional new business and go-to-market lead for founder-led agencies, helping them build pipeline that doesn’t ride on a few people. Mediation is making me better at the part of that work that matters most: getting leaders and managers onto one scoreboard.

If nothing fell apart, nothing new could be imagined. Meaningful change doesn’t need perfect conditions.

What crazy thing have you been putting off, where there’s a big need in the world?

If this sounds like your team, take the five-minute Two Scoreboards Diagnostic.

Is your team keeping two scoreboards?

Take the five-minute Two Scoreboards Diagnostic with one other leader. The gaps between your answers tell you where to start.

Leave a Reply